Like some other things I've done to rattle the cage of my Windows XP machine, the change to NTFS happened on a whim. I'm an old hand at tweaking out of boredom. I'll switch back sooner or later, though it will mean a reformat. Well boo freakin hoo, right? Who asked for trouble ??
After the deed had been done, I began to appreciate the drawbacks of the changeover where this user is concerned:
1) No more virus scans outside of XP with F-Prot Antivirus for DOS. Reason? It's in #6.
2) No more F-Prot scans within XP either. There are files that F-Prot just won't 'see' anymore, such as things I download from the net and try to scan. The difference between the way F-Prot worked before and now, is NTFS-- the only change that happened in the meantime. I'm making do with a couple of other antivirus programs.
3) More a puzzle than a problem... the System Volume Information folder now refuses to be deleted, though System Restore is totally disabled.
4) One of my applications somehow forgot that I'd registered it, and insisted I do it again. Re-registering was easy. I only wish I knew why it happened.
5) XP starts and restarts take longer now. Neither are slower by a lot, but it's noticable.
6) No more ability to restore Registry backups from outside of XP using ERUNT, a move that requires direct access to a FAT or FAT32-based hard disk from a bootable floppy diskette that is also FAT based. You might think of it as MS-DOS mode from previous versions of Windows. Then forget it!-- No-can-do with NTFS, no way I know of at least.
...later on...
Ok, I take back #5. After a scandisk and a defrag, the boot time seems to be back where it was before.
...later still...
I've definitely dropped F-Prot Antivirus for DOS, now using AVG Free Edition and AVERT Stinger, eliminating one major reason I stayed with FAT32 this long. I'm happy with AVG, though it has slowed things down.
Some things I collected:
- FAT & NTFS File Systems in Windows XP (Windows Support Center)
- FAT32 or NTFS: Making the Choice (The Elder Geek)
- Increase XP NTFS performance (Tech Republic)
![]() | ![]() |